Gransnet forums

Ask a gran

The National Anthem

(93 Posts)
Floradora9 Tue 29-Nov-22 19:59:22

Listening to it before the football to-night it struck me that it is the only anthem not about the country but just about the king or queen Surely it is time to change this . Cannot say I wanted to watch the football but DH does and he has had a bad day so deserves to watch it .

Yammy Thu 01-Dec-22 22:10:43

Bodach

"The Welsh sing "Oh land of my Fathers beautiful in Welsh", and the Scots "The flowers of the Forrest_".
Yammy: I think you probably mean "Flower of Scotland". "Flowers of the Forest" is a lament for the Scots killed at Flodden in 1513. A lovely song, but not a suitable national anthem..

Personally, I like" Scotland the brave."Sorry I got muddled up.

paddyann54 Thu 01-Dec-22 22:15:53

First problem I had with my late FIL was when I refused to stand for the National Anthem at a Masonic dinner .No chance in hell of me ever standing for it .I told him I would sit at the table or I would walk to the loo ...his choice .I walked to the loo

Mollygo Thu 01-Dec-22 22:51:36

Masonic Dinner- another close knit group like some see the RF and before you ask, yes. I am well acquainted with Freemasons through several generations. But at least you stood.

StoneofDestiny Thu 01-Dec-22 23:18:16

I'd stand for Flower of Scotland, but never in a million years for God Save the Queen, King or any other monarchic figure.

StoneofDestiny Thu 01-Dec-22 23:24:16

What’s wrong with Rule Britannia? A happy tune?

You need to ask?

StoneofDestiny Thu 01-Dec-22 23:28:34

Not Jerusalem. How many other countries would sing about establishing a foreign capital in our green and pleasant land.? How would Muslims, Hindus and other religions feel about that? Perhaps substitute Beijing or Washington? I know what Blake was referring to but that makes it a purely Christian hymn. Not relevant to our multi-cultural society

Apart from that, it's about Englands 'green and pleasant land', so not appropriate for anybody but the English

Mollygo Fri 02-Dec-22 09:08:28

StoneofDestiny, you’re right, and that’s the problem with so many songs that we sing enthusiastically. So many different cultures-even though they’re born in the UK, living in England and are happy to declare they’re British if asked, will make it difficult to find a song that will suit all.
In Jerusalem, that word was meant to be a place to aspire to for Christians. To my knowledge, neither Beijing, nor Washington are places we would aspire to be, and they don’t scan anyway. May just as well use Afghanistan

I thought we could maybe use the tune and the words of Jerusalem, but substitute Utopia for Jerusalem?
According to Merriam-Webster ,
Utopia is a place of ideal perfection especially in laws, government, and social conditions
So Till we have built Utopia in England’s Green and Pleasant land, could well be something to aspire to.
What do you think?

Mollygo Fri 02-Dec-22 09:11:08

Pressed post too quickly
Or Britain’s green and pleasant land

Casdon Fri 02-Dec-22 09:36:11

Jerusalem is a very controversial option - so controversial that when I got married the vicar would not allow it to be used in the ceremony.
www.spectator.co.uk/article/there-s-nothing-patriotic-about-william-blake-s-jerusalem

Callistemon21 Fri 02-Dec-22 09:41:58

StoneofDestiny

*Not Jerusalem. How many other countries would sing about establishing a foreign capital in our green and pleasant land.? How would Muslims, Hindus and other religions feel about that? Perhaps substitute Beijing or Washington? I know what Blake was referring to but that makes it a purely Christian hymn. Not relevant to our multi-cultural society*

Apart from that, it's about Englands 'green and pleasant land', so not appropriate for anybody but the English

England needs it's own Anthem too.
At sporting events when, for example, England plays Wales, the Welsh sing their anthem with gusto, the English have to sing the one which represents the whole of the UK.

Glorianny Fri 02-Dec-22 09:43:17

I remember our English teacher at school saying we wouldn't sing so enthusiastically if we really understood Blake's words.

As the English National Anthem there is always Flanders and Swan's "The English are Best" www.youtube.com/watch?v=m4zyfwtDIHE
Apologies to all from the other three countries. It is completely non-PC.

Lesley60 Fri 02-Dec-22 11:09:51

I’m so pleased that it’s not mine as I wouldn’t sing it, I’m Welsh and love ours

Eloethan Sat 03-Dec-22 16:49:03

Thanks Casdon.

OxfordGran Sun 18-Dec-22 12:13:48

Jerusalema? dance to the Anthem?

nanna8 Sun 18-Dec-22 12:23:45

I was thinking Land of Hope and Glory but that has rather unpleasant colonisation overtones. Jerusalem is regarded as blasphemous by many. There’ll always be an England ?

volver Sun 18-Dec-22 12:35:30

OxfordGran

Jerusalema? dance to the Anthem?

👏🏼

Lauren59 Wed 04-Jan-23 22:34:24

Zoejory

Maybe Living on a Prayer would do. Quite apt and everyone always sings along.

Ha! I love this idea. 🤣