Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Superfluous Superlatives

(21 Posts)
Elrel Sat 23-Sep-23 20:01:32

Yesterday evening I was irritated by a reporter on local tv news putting ‘most’ before a superlative. Today on Radio4 PM a presenter referred to ‘most toughest anti-smoking measures’.
Do these people really think that this is the most best way to express themselves?

absent Sat 23-Sep-23 21:22:19

A bit like very unique

Foxygloves Sat 23-Sep-23 21:37:43

Or even most bestest

grandtanteJE65 Sun 24-Sep-23 14:31:53

There used to be branches of the Danish co-op called, in what I do not doubt they fondly imagined was correct English: Superbest.

Grammar is no longer taught or learned at school, so things like "Very dead" to describe the condition of whatever the cat brought in, "very pregnant" to describe a woman nearing the end of her ninth month are just as common as the modified superlatives, and just as wrong, and to me irritating.

After all, death, life, pregnancy or for that matter viriginity are absolute states.

sodapop Sun 24-Sep-23 14:45:32

The number of times I hear "small little" is increasing in line with the use of "of" instead of "have" which irritates the hell out of me.

crazyH Sun 24-Sep-23 14:49:40

absent - I can hear myself say “very unique” 😂

Witzend Sun 24-Sep-23 14:55:14

Any R4 presenter really ought to know better, but the Beeb does seem bent on dumbing down nowadays.

vampirequeen Sun 24-Sep-23 15:33:21

English is a constantly evolving language. This is just part of its evolution.

Elrel Mon 25-Sep-23 00:06:34

Vampire queen - Indeed it is. I find myself saying ‘train station’ instead of ‘railway station’ to fit with other people. So far I have not referred to bus seats as ‘chairs’ however.

nanna8 Mon 25-Sep-23 00:14:27

A totally unique thread with absolute truths.

NotSpaghetti Mon 25-Sep-23 08:17:33

absent

A bit like very unique

My personal bugbear! angry

NotSpaghetti Mon 25-Sep-23 08:35:25

Completely unique is another.

NotSpaghetti Mon 25-Sep-23 08:36:17

Or 'quite unique'

Namsnanny Mon 25-Sep-23 12:49:25

nanna8

A totally unique thread with absolute truths.

😂

sodapop Mon 25-Sep-23 12:53:10

I'll just add the evolving language comment to any post I make in Pedants Corner to save other posters having to do it every time.

welbeck Mon 25-Sep-23 12:58:05

nanna8

A totally unique thread with absolute truths.

but are they true facts ?

Baggs Mon 25-Sep-23 13:00:30

Thanks, soda 😅

And nanna8 😂🤣

Baggs Mon 25-Sep-23 13:02:30

To do a wrecked quote ad absurdum:

Rage, rage against the dying of the right grammar!

Grantanow Wed 04-Oct-23 17:24:28

I'm not so sure about 'very dead', etc. It is of course wrong when used in the sense of 'highly' or ' exceedingly' but the original Latin meaning is 'truly' as in church Latin 'verily I say unto you' so it may be that there is an underlying meaning of 'truly dead' which persists.

Witzend Tue 09-Jan-24 09:05:16

I forget which TV programme it was on, but a little boy was telling how he’d gone to feed his hamster one morning, but, ‘He was a bit dead really.’ 😂 (😰)

grandtanteJE65 Thu 11-Jan-24 16:34:30

sodapop

I'll just add the evolving language comment to any post I make in Pedants Corner to save other posters having to do it every time.

Forgive me, Sodapop, but I feel you have rather missed the point of Pedant's corner.

WE KNOW language evolves, but we happen to believe that not all changes are good or necessary and that some are purely ridiculous.

Most of us are, doubtless, content with new words or expressions that there really is a need for, but not with slovenly use of language, which in my opinion modified superlatives clearly are.